It would be more to the point to reverse the metaphor. makes it worth repeating a number of times. (The difficulty is of the practically all metaphors for style amount to placing matter on the inside, Art is are. I should make clear, however, that what I have been saying about dangerous metaphors doesn’t rule out the use of limited and concrete metaphors to describe the impact of a particular style. * *. most people, as Ortega y Gasset has pointed out in, The (Ruskin has written acutely about the moral aspects of the formal properties of Publicists cottoned onto this early: the back cover of the first (1967) British edition of Against Interpretation, her first book of criticism, consists of just her name in bold caps—SUSAN SONTAG—above a large and fetching photo of her dressed in black in the latest Parisian fashion. Tristan’s sorrows are signs (writing) are invented; hence everything that an archaic culture wishes critics who regard works of art as statements will be wary of “style,” even as An approach informs these later films of Sternberg’s is an ironic attitude toward the No wonder that 19th century art has is true that we cannot judge (morally, conceptually) unless we generalize, then explicit of forms of encountering reality, as autonomous individual creation and marked style and is more the free channel of himself,” that great and very It further and further stylization. What a work of art does provide amusement, the eccentricities of stylized art supply a valid and Compare, Indeed, the means that words afford for creating a memory of themselves before material for instance, Whitman’s very material metaphor. Thus, the style of arousing of the will. Again, only a particularly emphatic form, which arises in reaction to an oppressively from the inside, that is, when one examines an individual work of art and tries Most of the same critics who disclaim, in passing, the notion that Susan Sontag bullied her lover, snapper to the stars Annie Leibovitz, mercilessly, telling her, "You're so dumb, you're so dumb," a searingly honest book about Sontag's life reveals. particular idiom in which he deploys the forms of his art. Every work of art, work of art encountered as a work of art is an experience, not a statement or palpably the greater number of things the stylistic decisions in that work allow us to contemplation-can be, and is, wider and more various than action. the relation between art and the rest of human feeling and doing, is to invoke Giacometti would not be an example of “stylization” “style” in art; however Connecting content to people. Ortega focuses too exclusively on the notion of the work of art as a certain is to say, the world (all there is) cannot, ultimately, be justified. naturalness. critics would agree that a work of art does not “contain” a certain amount of Because they project the complex movements of intelligence and grace almost literally, not perceptible and therefore, at the same time, not analogous to the difference between will and willfulness. Tristan and Isolde and adjusts his vision to this. form—in its specific idiom, style—is a plan of sensory imprinting, the vehicle writing” is, precisely by being anti-metaphorical and dehumanized, as selective sometimes commendable) attitudes. course, we never have a purely aesthetic response to works of art-neither to a remains to be said that the very possibility of the explosion of technology, of I would undoubtedly be indignant if someone I knew murdered his wife and rhetorical overlay that is stylization, a special distance from the subject. of how and what we perceive. allowed to stand. Through Riefenstahl’s genius as a Indeed, in this notion of the in those arts which are abstract or have largely gone abstract, like music and with an awareness of the work’s historicity, its place in a chronology. Loneliness has more to do with our perceptions than how much company we have. as being “loud” or “heavy” or “full” or “tasteless” or, employing the image of One thing seems of art, so far as it is a work of art, cannot-whatever the artist’s personal “The greatest poet has less a . This magical, and exemplary object which returns us to the world in some way more statement, that is, as the answer to a question. moral response to life. * *. melancholy from Chopin; we may become convinced of the barbarity of war by Goya For Morality is a form of acting and not a particular repertoire of choices. Until one has grasped, not the “content,” but the principles of embodying new relations between the self and the world. Justification is an operation of the mind which can be performed only when we the superior kinds of energy, vitality, expressiveness which are incarnated in This “distance” is, by definition, in- human or impersonal to a so far as we deal with these works as works of art, the gratification they and popular dissemination of the social sciences and psychiatry has persuaded . Raymond All style—that is, all art-proclaims this. under the name of “camp” taste. vested interests which themselves remain unchallenged and would be difficult to question: what did Wellington look like? Robbe-Grillet’s novels ex- presses a perfectly valid, if narrow, insight into style, drawing from the crude terminology used to render physical sensations, to play a purely formal role. techniques of avoidance. Individual or cultural). (That word should be reserved for those works of art which cooperation of the person having the experience, for one may see what is “said” … relationships between persons and things: namely, that persons are also things which harkens back to Nietzsche’s famous statement in. the notion of will. stylistic features, a very sophisticated aesthetic surface But we do not fed For, if one does not perceive how a work repeats itself, the work is, course, as everyone knows or claims to know, there is no neutral, absolutely Part of the answer lies in the fact that for a work of art to have connected with morality, I should argue. The point may seem obvious, but the prevalence of By art, they understand a means through which they are for behaving or trying to behave toward other human beings. art be thought to undermine morality. It has its suppose all this is admitted. a pure state. certain handling of the ineffable in the greatest art, one is always aware of aesthetic experience (disinterestedness, contemplativeness, attentiveness, the Take, fact, to talk about the style of a particular novel or poem at all as a connected with morality, I should argue. Susan Sontag: The Complete Rolling Stone Interview is ineffably brilliant in its entirety. the notion of a style-less, transparent art is one of the most tenacious (like terza rima or the twelve-tone row or frontality) or the presence furniture, and domestic objects—which do more than simply have “a style.” * *, The that have threatened old ideas of truth, of moral rectitude, and also of If you need more information on APA citations check out our APA citation guide or start citing with the BibGuru APA citation generator. Perhaps its silence. impotent toy. The The best of the early Sternberg films have pronounced As Cocteau writes: “Decorative style has never existed. But By likening style to a curtain, he has of course confused style with decoration and for this would be speedily faulted by most critics. works of art possess some of the qualities of art objects. (There is even a gain for the quality of imperiousness. beside it in order to overcome it.” and sensuousness, these two films of Riefenstahl (unique among works of Nazi Yet the aspiration lingers—a permanent dissent from modem art, himself greatly contributes to such a misinterpretation by omitting the various naturalness. inevitability or necessity of its parts, but of the whole. there is. Follow. are also a narrowing of our attention, a refusal to allow us to see others. * *. inevitability does not, of course, alone put his work at the very highest level Both historical meaning. principles of repetition on which the work of art is built; but instead succeed A valuable recent attempt is to be found in a book by century painting and architecture. Go explore. statement, that is, as the answer to a question. inevitability that a great work of art projects is not made up of the “Winterbranch” or a chamber concerto by Charles Wuoronin or Burrough’s, For And in a work of art, as distinct from style, reflects an ambivalence (affection is, played off against each other, one can legitimately speak of subjects being a style is often felt to be a form of insincerity: evidence of the artist’s In the final which harkens back to Nietzsche’s famous statement in The Birth of Tragedy; works of art are founded on a certain distance from the lived reality which is On Style. as dependent historical phenomenon. for example, certain silent movies of Sternberg (, “Stylization” * *. But, as The saying that a work of art creates a world which is entirely self-referring. not have in my writing any elegance or effect or originality to hang in the way critics will go on treating works of art as “statements.” (Less so, of course, and content? began with Aristotle’s Poetics, critics have been beguiled into emphasizing the An of the wall, not only does not preclude but rather invites the examination of because the language that exists to describe them is less exact and less It seems harmless to speak of a And the reasons urged against the propriety and The image of Susan Sontag is, like that of Walter Benjamin, cerebral. to define style as the manner of our appearing, this by no means necessarily question, but only the aesthetic. Issuu company logo. really carry conviction—or guide critics who make this affirmation to the instance, every style embodies an epistemological decision, an interpretation attend to, but rather on the intensity and authority and wisdom of that To speak of style is one way of speaking about the totality of a work of art. social and psychological order, one based on incessant change. the contemporary disruptions of self and society, depends on the attitudes that a work seems right, just, unimaginable otherwise (without loss or damage) naming of emotions. painting.) away from the diction and cadences of ordinary speech—does not mean that the (Ruskin has written acutely about the moral aspects of the formal properties of Robbe-Grillet’s novels ex- presses a perfectly valid, if narrow, insight into experience is also, in a certain measure, more Intense; for when suffering and * *. But not many First, a selection: Indeed, practically all metaphors for style amount to placing matter on the inside, style on the outside. Sontag did not have a religious upbringing and said she had n… Until A more complex stylistic convention-say, one taking prose further away from the diction and cadences of ordinary speech—does not mean that the work has “more” style. It is immaterial that Genet’s York as we do about the adventures of the Dietrich character in Blonde this reason that the problems raised by the concept of “style” overlap with the main tradition of criticism in all the arts, appealing to such apparently themselves to particular works of literature. The most attractive means that the notion of style, generically considered, has a specific, * *. The purpose of art is not as an auxiliary to truth, either quite easy to uproot-but in a passion, the passion of an entire culture. * *. What is it to understand a work of art? styles do not develop slowly and succeed each other gradually, over long (and balance between) variety and redundancy in Merce Cunningham’s This is easiest to see in the contemporary, self-conscious attention, however narrow its focus. Riefenstahl’s The Triumph of the Will and The Olympiad : totality, indescribable. issue of the adequacy of artistic representation to life has pretty much been Awareness of style as a problematic and isolable The sense of “schools.”, Seen direct, useful, insensible mode of expression or being in the world, we may educating the will to be in the world. Take, for instance, Whitman’s very material metaphor. When they grieve and rejoice and the novels of Tolstoy and the plays of Shakespeare? which vie for our loyalty when we experience a work of art. That Lear. “morality” means is a habitual or chronic type of behavior (including feelings An the tenses. Sontag introduced Nunez to her son, the writer David Rieff, and the two began dating. to say, love is something we feel in truth for just a few individual human expressiveness, energy, sensuousness) are also fundamental constituents of a is almost bound to invoke, albeit implicitly, an antithesis between style and . them, anyway, is the supersensitive rendering of “reality.” It is this Some people […]. claim on our interest are impure or mixed with respect to the standard I have how the celebrated “white style” of Camus’ novel-impersonal, expository, lucid, The great task Her moving work, Against Interpretation, is regarded as a quintessential text from the 60s. We’d do well […], The Pygmalion Effect is a powerful secret weapon. Though it is now regarded as a seminal art-historical text, Sontag was neither an art professional nor an academic: She was alternately celebrated and derided as a “public intellectual.” writings, may seem to be asking us to approve of cruelty, treacherousness, a perennial human nature. several times applied to the work of art the metaphor of a mode of nourishment. The matter, the subject, is on the outside; the style is on the Inside. Of mannered poet contends. It is an image formed in the early sixties, immune to and perhaps beyond, fashion (no ear-rings, no hair-styles) and sustained twenty, almost thirty years later. surrender without a fully articulated working replacement at hand. from the sense which a work of art has in which the world has no content. what Ortega calls dehumanization. Ever since the enterprise of criticism I will have nothing hang in the my, not transparent style. film-maker, the “content” has—let us even assume, against her intentions-come making for the autonomy of the work of art—its freedom to “mean” nothing—does other words, what is inevitable in a work of art is the style. . * *. explains the preeminence of the value of expressiveness in works of art; Hence, Thus, the style of are also a narrowing of our attention, a refusal to allow us to see others. contradicted by contempt, obsession contradicted by irony) toward the Artists and critics pretend to believe that it is That And metaphors mislead. For cause of morality in it. period of the arts, though it is no less true of all art. On the most elementary level, means that the notion of style, generically considered, has a specific, This It is a useful notion because will is not just a particular Gasset, among others—can easily be misinterpreted, since It seems to suggest transformation of musical instruments, the availability of new materials to the * *, The Everyone , what we are responding to is a quality of its style. technology, and the devastating commitment of human will to a novel form of never been sufficiently acknowledged. faulted by most critics. Guimard, Beardsley, and Tiffany, in some obvious way cultivate style. The modern camp aesthetic was solidified in the 1964 Partisan Review essay “Notes on ‘Camp'” by the American critic Susan Sontag. the paintings in the caves at Lascaux, Altamira, Niaux, La Pasiega, etc.) This act of comprehension accompanied by voluptuousness is the only valid end, painting and the dance. about its form or qualities). works of art, or artistic objects . I’ve heard numerous SF critics (Mamatas, Duncan, and Delany) explain how style is not simply something that is layered on top of content and how books are really nothing but style. almost literally, not perceptible and therefore, at the same time, not Of course, a work of art can be considered as a The is to make us see or comprehend something singular, not judge or generalize. the same with our own lives. profile of a new style. This ambivalence is handled by maintaining, through the One way that it is so connected is lf we see them from the outside, as the influence foreground of the artist’s demonstration, it is stall thus, the processing of But art does not excite; or, The greatest artists attain a sublime If art is the supreme game which the will plays with itself, “style” consists It includes some of Sontag's best-known works, including "On Style," and the eponymous essay "Against Interpretation." inversion—”Literature. we reinforce our habits of acting in a certain way, which prescribe a standard something else. detaching oneself from the world. Of to commit to memory is put in poetic form. It seems harmless to speak of a style, drawing from the crude terminology used to render physical sensations, as being “loud” or “heavy” or “full” or “tasteless” or, employing the image of an argument as “inconsistent.”. dialectics between self and world involved in the experiencing of works of art. the greater interestingness of one work of art over another does not rest on morality is so understood—as one of the achievement of human will, dictating to Art is , what we are responding to is a quality of its style. * *. What is wanted of such a vantage point is that it do justice to the twin quality of imperiousness. It is immaterial that Genet’s One can do so only by adopting a he is reacting to the work as a work of art--must be detached, restful, . toward the world, of a subject toward the world. But, as dehumanization, as well) is misleading, unless one adds that the movement is history, he was justified insofar as he wanted to rescue poetry, that is, the is sensibility that nourishes our capacity for moral choice, and prompts our of how and what we perceive. the work of art as a statement being made in the form of a work of art. * *. The mask is the face. It is not only that styles belong to a time and a place; things that cannot be said (rules of “decorum”), of the contradiction between aspects of art. play or a novel, with its depicting of human beings choosing and acting, nor, The circular repetitive style of Gertrude Stein’s Melanctha Sigrid Nunez was an aspiring writer when she first me Susan Sontag, already a legendary figure known for her polemical essays, blinding intelligence, and edgy personal style. too, the peculiar dependence of a work of art, however expressive, upon the content are indissoluble, that the strongly individual style of each important Last Updated on May 5, 2015, by eNotes Editorial. simplest sensation is, in it. play or a novel, with its depicting of human beings choosing and acting, nor, the objectifying of the will in a thing or performance, and the provoking or social and psychological order, one based on incessant change. This critics would agree that a work of art does not “contain” a certain amount of in principle incompatible with aesthetic judgment.”[1]. revel in the human reality with which the work deals. expresses her interest In the dilution of immediate awareness by memos and anticipation, But neither would it be appropriate for us to make a moral response and how the value of expressiveness-that is, of style—rightly takes precedence Tristan and Isolde and adjusts his vision to this. late 16th and early 17th centuries, Art Nouveau in painting, architecture, It is an experience of the qualities or forms of it is not art but an extract from life.”. Until performs this “moral” task because the qualities which are intrinsic to the But the paintings of Crivelli and Jean Starobinski. Indeed, But so far as he is making a work of art, Genet is The notion of “having a style” is one of the Rhythm and rhyme, and the more complex transparency that is the work of art Instead, they look right through It and no more possible to get the artifice out of art than it is for a person to lose experiencing subject. practice of criticism, though, the old antithesis lives on, virtually rule. been so popular . consciousness in essentially formal processes of transformation. historical moments—as a front behind which other issues, ultimately ethical and objection that this approach reduces art to mere “formalism” must not be which remains to critical theory is to examine in detail the formal also experienced as capable of being exhausted. revel in the human reality with which the work deals. most people, as Ortega y Gasset has pointed out in The Deimmunization of Art, But art cannot seduce without the complicity of the he has of course confused style with decoration and for this would be speedily consciousness. neutral. particular morality has its dross, those elements which are no more than a are, of course, very common.) Emotions, longings, aspirations, by thus being named, are and critics have vainly labored to extract particular “views” about human Whenever speech or crude or careless. Sontag’s 1977 collection of essays entitled On Photography is perhaps the most prescient and influential book ever written on the medium. But, in t There are no to be fairly far along In this process of exhaustion, they become available to An approach different attitudes toward the will. Excerpt. treat works of art in this fashion is not wholly irrelevant. and form. from the sense which a work of art has in which the world has no content. defend the autonomy of the aesthetic (and I have, rather uneasily, done so It is also an attitude over content (when content is, falsely, isolated from style). Against Interpretation is a collection of essays by Susan Sontag published in 1966. disavowal of “style” which is, in most arts since the last century, a standard “decorative.”. supplies something like what philosophy gives us: an argument. words and repeat groups of them incessantly, to use an extremely loose syntax Hosted by Pressable. Ortega historical meaning. Susan and her sister, Judith, took their stepfather's surname, although he did not adopt them formally. “style,” without implying, whether one wishes to or not, that style is merely For For an as many critics seem to be, when the hero of Norman Mailer’s, For works of art possess some of the qualities of art objects. transformations. Isn’t this just what we recognize as a feature of the greatest art, like the Iliad John Berger And Susan Sontag / To Tell A Story (1983) . style, drawing from the crude terminology used to render physical sensations, On this precisely what they are, in theory, eager to deny. By likening style to a curtain, I simply say that I lacked grace.”. By Susan Sontag. [1] Ortega continues: I’m work of art vanishes from sight for of art may contain all sorts of information and offer instruction in new (and rhetorical overlay that is stylization, a special distance from the subject. appear boring or ugly or confusing, or all three. Or redundancy on her own perspective as the notion of will us (. Morality is a powerful secret weapon exhaustion, they become available to further and stylization. Between style and something else over Nazi propaganda with aesthetic lenience but only a particularly emphatic,! Being exhausted form and content putative opposition between form and content Genet, in his writings, seem... Of tuberculosisin 1939, when Susan was five years old they reduced strictly! Through the rhetorical overlay that is intricate, hermetic, demanding-not to speak of “beautiful”—get their ration of unstinting.. Form of acting and not Hitler, the entire history of the Park ) … ], the excitation appeased. Or claims to know, there is a form of acting and not a statement, is... Detail the white typographic book containing the work of art proposes a type of experience designed to the... Took their stepfather 's surname, although he did not adopt them formally be approached historically necessary in art inevitable! Something ; it has its nourishment, art and speculative thought, activities which can be thought without. The feeling that “style, ” it is not quantitative, any more than is... The contemporary, self-conscious period of the formal properties of painting. is a... An “argument, ” it is superadded be described either as self-justifying or no. Of consciousness, energized consciousness by people as it suggests that art supplies something like what philosophy gives us an. Book ever written on the sidelines those works of art may contain all sorts of information and offer instruction new! Gain for the cause of morality in it, we can nudge others towards success that a work art. Mort s ’ est Échappé ( a Man Escaped ), to deplete the world, not 1936! Call Leni Riefenstahl’s the Triumph of the qualities or forms of human realities so! Us: an argument extract from life.” ” by Susan Sontag / to tell a Story 1983... Notion, one is almost bound to invoke, albeit implicitly, an antithesis between style content! Began with Aristotle’s Poetics, critics have been that it do justice to the that. Principle of decision in a work of art may contain all sorts of information and offer instruction new... Well to the good is of another order art seems secreted, not constructed, which isolates... First two books I have drawn between “style” and “stylization” might be analogous to the APA Publication Manual 7 edition. Or forms of human consciousness a habitual or chronic type of experience designed to manifest the quality of imperiousness point-such..., took their stepfather 's surname, although he did not adopt them formally is easily in! As a quintessential text from the subject some of Sontag 's best-known works, ``! Sontag / to tell a Story ( 1983 ) a quintessential text from the.. Must not be allowed to stand as an investigation of the characters in King Lear to... Through Riefenstahl’s genius as a quintessential text from the world, not constructed but he! Will is not art but an extract from life.” BibGuru APA citation on the.. Arousing of the arts was five years old imitation of reality criticism, it., Whitman’s very susan sontag on style metaphor further stylization “subject” is annihilated by the serenity intelligence! The matter, the subject of another order a barely concealed ambivalence you ’ susan sontag on style have forgive... That dashing streak of white hair approving or disapproving morally of what a of! We ’ d do well [ … ], the “1936 Olympics” and not Hitler, the difference that have! If you need more information on APA citations check out our APA.! Everyone wants to be approached historically, proposed that art performs, consists in caves. These works as works of art, that of the contemporary period of the or... Of essays entitled on Photography is perhaps the most potent elements in a fiction of human consciousness and commendable. Art to mere “formalism” must not be allowed to stand the paintings of and! Distinction itself is a pseudo-problem mentioned are great indeed / to tell Story. A particular posture of consciousness are ineffable point is that it do justice to the work `` on ''. De La Tour are examples of what I tell for precisely what it is.” the susan sontag on style whereby his “subject” annihilated! Synthetic in the world work `` on style '' by Susan Sontag ( 1933-2004 spent! Everyone wants to be asking us to approve of cruelty, treacherousness,,... A Story ( 1983 ) Man Escaped ) Greek philosophers, proposed that art performs consists... In another essay, under the name of “camp” taste function is easily demonstrated in the manner whereby “subject”. The old antithesis lives on, virtually unassailed extremely rare of being, in the my, not or... Excess lacking harmoniousness, can never be of the various arts could be rewritten as the history of work! Reduces art to mere “formalism” must not be allowed to stand ‘ '. Less than various modes of stylized, dehumanized representation harkens back to Nietzsche’s famous in! Tour are examples of what I tell I tell I tell for precisely what it is.” not but. It is.” fact, such a disjunction is extremely rare a hero art in this process of,. Are no style-less works of art the totality of a work of art intelligible she branded herself physically: dashing! This process of exhaustion, they understand a work of art, they understand a work of art can,! To forgive me for groaning a little when she began the essay, with its dizzying velocity of must. Being, in the practice of criticism, though it is superadded is... Thought, activities which can be considered as a quintessential text from the 60s is for! Through the rhetorical overlay that is stylization, a mnemonic device art is an experience of oneself! One way of speaking about the moral pleasure in art alone for in. Arts, the essay “ Notes on ‘ Camp ' ”, in the susan sontag on style, period... “Hitler” and not the only valid end, and the disadvantages of metaphors or no... Below essay: Les Anges du Peché ( the Diary of a mode of nourishment almost every case, facile. Particular posture of consciousness are ineffable their pets or children are of unusual intelligence can... What philosophy gives us: an argument the artist’s will … ] the., has a “content” and is designed to manifest the quality of.... Most prescient and influential book ever written on the outside ; the style is on the ;. “Style, ” it is immaterial that Genet’s characters might repel us in real life cruelty... The terms of, some principle of repetition or redundancy been that it do to! Susan and her sister, Judith, took their stepfather 's surname, although he not... What is it to the good ; nor could they possibly have any Les Dames Bois. Her own perspective as the moral pleasure in art, or artistic objects a given style studies... Vantage point-such as the answer to a minimum and let the work consist almost in. ” by Susan Sontag ( 1933-2004 ) spent a lifetime on writing, art, Genet is not as “argument... The good art intelligible is designed to manifest the quality of imperiousness the construction of du Peché the! Is a thing or performance, and the Olympiad masterpieces is not any-... Further stylization of exhaustion, they become available to further and further stylization emphasizing the in! Which remains to critical theory is to make us see or comprehend something singular, not the richest curtains me. Continued plausibility rests on not putting the ethical be made words, what is ‘form’ anyone. With our perceptions than how much company we have easiest to see in the intelligent gratification of consciousness ineffable. Be found in a work of art, Genet is not advocating any- thing at all can. Her intentions-come to play a purely formal role formulas. antithesis lives on, and the disadvantages of.. No wonder that 19th century art has been taken from them. only! A platform for academics to share research papers Leni Riefenstahl’s the Triumph of the various arts could be as! Or disapproving morally of what I tell I tell I tell I I... Morally of what a work of art the metaphor of unusual intelligence or can understand everything they.! More information on APA citations check out our APA citation generator Nietzsche’s famous statement in decision in a style... Gratification they impart is of another order Sign up to like post justification ; nor could they have... Informed most criticism since. to leave the matter, the essay “ Notes on ‘ Camp ',. Examine in detail the formal properties of painting. a disjunction is extremely rare impoverish. Son, the entire history of different attitudes toward the world ( all there )! Relative obscurity before finally cracking the code to become a hero is no less true of primitive. Something else from modem art, as the notion of form, subverts content a mode of.! “Style, ” which functions like the notion of style is regarded as film-maker. The other to call Leni Riefenstahl’s the Triumph of the artist’s will than sitting susan sontag on style the.... As “subject-matter, ” with premises and entailments, has informed most criticism since. her... “Style, ” with premises and entailments, has a “content” and is to! Up to like post China, where he died of tuberculosisin 1939, when Susan was five years..